Pretzel Logo
Why PretzelGiving Back
Refinance Car Illustration
Facebook iconTwitter iconInstagram iconPinterest icon
Finance

Can I Refinance My Car with the Same Lender?

Can I refinance my car with the same lender? It's a common question, especially when you're comfortable with your current financial institution. Loyalty is admirable, but it doesn't always translate to the best auto loan refinance rates. This guide explores whether sticking with your existing loan for a car refinance makes financial sense, or if branching out might be the smarter move to save money.

Refinancing Basics

Refinancing a car loan replaces your current auto loan with a new one, often with adjusted loan terms and loan rates. People refinance for several reasons. Lower monthly payments free up cash, while a shorter loan term reduces overall interest paid. Many seek lower interest rates on car loans for long-term savings.

Can I Refinance My Car With the Same Lender? The Pros and Cons

Yes, you can often refinance your car with the same lender. It's convenient, as they already have your information. A good payment history might help you secure better terms, and it’s nice staying with a familiar company.

However, convenience isn’t everything. Your current lender may not offer the best deal. They might even have limitations based on your financial situation preventing a refinance, even if your original loan is with them.

Don't let convenience overshadow potential savings. Shopping around for car refinancing options, especially using tools like an auto refinance calculator, is easy and can potentially save you a significant amount of money.

Why Shop Around Even If Your Current Lender Says “Yes”

Understanding auto loans, loan refinance rates, and refinancing offers requires attention to detail, even if the lender claims it’s straightforward. Get your free credit report to understand your creditworthiness. Lenders consider credit scores when offering auto loan refinance rates.

Another lender might offer a lower auto loan refinance rate, dramatically reducing the total interest paid. Loan terms vary too. A shorter loan term with a different lender means faster repayment and less interest, even if monthly payments are slightly higher. Longer repayment periods lower monthly payments but increase the total interest paid.

Lender

APR Range

Minimum Credit Score

Loan Term (Months)

Loan Amount

BestAutoRefinance.ai

5.24%–29.9%

500

24–84

$5,000–$100,000+

RefiJet

5.29%–21.99%

500

24–96

$5,000–$150,000

Gravity Lending

4.99%–17.99%

500

36–84

$3,000–$250,000

Autopay

4.67%–23.80%

560

12-96

$8,000-No max.

Auto Approve

5.24%-24.55%

620

12-84

$10,000-$150,000

Capital One

Depends on credit profile

N/A

36-72

Starting at $4,000

Shop around for the best refinance rates even if your current lender offers you a car refinance. Your current financial situation, including any credit card debt or personal loans, could impact your refinance options.

When It's Probably Not a Good Idea to Stay

Assess your creditworthiness and finances before refinancing. A free credit score check from Credit Karma can be a starting point. Consider if now’s the right time to refinance, and which lender is right for you.

Some auto loans carry prepayment penalties. Refinancing might not be beneficial, especially with another lender, unless the interest savings outweigh the penalty.

Refinancing becomes especially advantageous if interest rates have dropped or if your credit health significantly improved since your original auto loan. Improved credit scores can help secure a more favorable interest rate.

Doing Your Homework Before You Refinance

Prepayment penalties can offset any potential interest savings from a lower annual percentage rate (APR), no matter how appealing. Evaluate all potential loan offers before choosing a refinancing option. Avoid lenders that have any record of predatory lending practices, even if the advertised refinance rates seem exceptionally favorable.

Carefully consider the loan terms. A longer loan term results in lower monthly car payments but more interest paid over time. A shorter term reduces the overall interest despite higher monthly payments. Consider debt consolidation if you have multiple high-interest debts and would benefit financially from streamlining payments into one.

Refinancing offers a way to potentially adjust your current car loan to a better interest rate and terms. Even with past credit worries, improved credit scores might lead to better refinance offers. This is especially true if current refinance rates have dropped. Getting your free credit score and evaluating your overall credit health before starting can give you a better idea of your refinancing prospects.

Lenders might hesitate to refinance cars older than ten years or with over one hundred thousand miles. Research your car's current market value using resources like Kelley Blue Book or J.D. Power. Consider fees like balance transfers, transfer fees, origination fees, early payoff penalties, or any potential prepayment penalties before refinancing.

If overwhelmed, utilize free resources like Credit Sesame, Experian, or the Credit Karma auto refinance calculator for additional information on car loans, refinance loans, and how much you could save money. Check your credit report for inaccuracies or signs of identity theft before making decisions about taking on more debt.

How Refinancing Impacts Your Credit Score

Refinancing involves a hard inquiry on your credit report when lenders assess your application. Be sure to check sites like the Better Business Bureau. Ensure your potential lender engages in fair lending practices.

Each hard pull can temporarily lower your credit score, typically by a few points. Refinancing car loans can offer better terms and rates.

Closing your original auto loan to refinance affects the average age of your credit accounts. While less impactful than payment history, a younger credit history might slightly lower your credit score unless your credit behavior is impeccable. Ensure the benefits of auto loan refinancing, such as lower monthly payments, outweigh potential impacts on credit scores.

A Quick History of Auto Loans

Car loan history is fascinating. Understanding this history empowers consumers to make better decisions when getting car loans, seeking personal loans, refinancing current loans, and securing more competitive rates. Getting favorable terms and making consistent monthly payments contributes positively to one’s financial standing.

General Motors pioneered auto financing in the U.S., becoming the original lender in this market. Auto loan refinancing and even personal loan refinancing have become significant components of personal finance and are readily available.

Conclusion

Can you refinance a car with the same lender? Yes. Should you? That depends on your individual circumstances. Thorough research and comparing refinance offers from different lenders, including considering factors like a prepayment penalty, free credit, and available balance transfers are essential.

Don’t settle for the convenience of your current lender. Shop around for potentially better deals, including a lower annual percentage rate (APR) or more favorable loan terms. This small effort may yield substantial savings, both now and in the future. Car refinancing empowers you to achieve long-term financial health.

Your credit score influences lender offers. Carefully weigh all options and select a refinancing plan that truly benefits you. Checking what lenders offer can help decide if refinancing your car elsewhere is a good option and align with your credit profile. Refinancing allows you to get out of unfavorable interest rates and loan terms and to gain control over car payments, and even helps some with bad credit secure better loan terms.

Arrow leftBack to all Posts
Finance
Facebook iconTwitter iconInstagram iconPinterest icon

More Blog Posts

Pretzel Logo
Facebook iconTwitter iconInstagram iconPinterest icon
PlansFAQLogin
ServicesAboutNewsroomJoin the team
Lets Stay in touch!
Subscribe to our newsletter